Dir. Ti West · 2026 · 116 min · PG-13 · in cinemas

This is a critical reading built from published reviews, the film's own materials and its production facts, not a first-hand viewing. Sources are linked below.

The setup

Paramount's Ebenezer is Charles Dickens's A Christmas Carol as directed by Ti West, best known for horror, from a script by Nathaniel Halpern. Johnny Depp plays Scrooge, in what Variety's trailer coverage called his first Hollywood studio film in eight years. The supporting cast is deep: Ian McKellen as Marley, Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit, Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman and Robert Strange as the three ghosts, with Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley and Ellie Bamber around them.

According to the reviews, the first thing West does is add a prologue: Marley is still alive, working alongside Scrooge. The story then moves through Dickens's five "staves", announced on screen, in a fog-choked London.

What works

Almost every critic agrees on the atmosphere. The A.V. Club's Jesse Hassenger praises the ghostly, haunted-house feel and calls the blend of practical and digital effects "uncommonly strong". Dread Central's Matt Konopka likewise likes the gothic mood and calls the ghosts the scariest take on the story while staying family-friendly. The Boston Globe's Odie Henderson, who is otherwise harsh, concedes that the sets and costumes are very well done and singles out Riseborough and McKellen. Tillman gets picked out in two reviews as the one actor who matches Depp.

What doesn't

The argument is about Depp, and the critics split hard. JoBlo's Chris Bumbray says he is terrific and that this is his best vehicle in a long time; Absolute Geeks calls him a brilliant monster but a lesser saint, convincing as the miser and less so once Scrooge softens. Hassenger finds him flat and hammy, Konopka says the over-the-top performance undermines the redemption arc, and Henderson, giving one star, calls him a hollow shell.

Depp's sincerity, however, still comes flavored with dinner-theater ham

Jesse Hassenger, The A.V. Club

The second complaint is familiarity. Several reviews say that after the horror-flavoured trailers they expected a fresh revision, and found a close, beat-for-beat adaptation of the book with some extra backstory. Konopka also finds the computer-generated ghosts weak, and Absolute Geeks says the pacing sags in the middle.

The scoreboard

Five reviews, five different verdicts. Scales are the outlets' own and are not always stated, so this is the gist, not a sum.

OutletCriticTheir verdict
The A.V. ClubJesse HassengerC+
The Boston GlobeOdie HendersonOne star
JoBloChris Bumbray8, "Great"
Dread CentralMatt Konopka2.0
Absolute GeeksMarwan S.3.8 out of 5

Is it for you?

Tick what applies. This is a rough guide built from what the critics say, not a verdict.

Tick a few to see where you land.

Where to watch

It is a cinema release. Time Out London's November preview lists a UK opening on 13 November, and the A.V. Club gives the same date for the US. Release dates and availability vary by country, so check your local listings.